solitonmedic's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Train Scene From Spirit Away]

A good start, the animation is bit jaggy and awkward looking but the composition is okay.

bornracer responds:

can you please explain what do you mean by awkward looking?? will helping me in the future thank you

[The Meckel Siblings Episode 3 "The Intelligent and handsome detective meckel" | Kotoon]

Pretty hilarious! The art style reminds me of Eddsworld in a way while being totally original in its own.

Not bad!

Koray98 responds:

When i was a kid he inspired the way i draw.You're right he is one of my biggest insperations :)
And he will be always in our hearts
Thank you

[Boston Wanderer Ep 1]

Stiff animation all around, dated graphics but functional.

Definitely improvements can be made!

AceXMason responds:

Thank you for the feedback! The next episode should be better than this one :)

[Alien Promo?]

What am I looking at, exactly? This doesn't even look like a trailer of sorts, more like some half-baked speed paint.

What are the viewers supposed to expect from watching this?

TvWeWe responds:

Some people like it, some don't. Just linking to my website with my other work is all that is being done with this video. thanks for the feedback though.

[Super Mario Bros. R Ending 1]

Very nice improvement, the animation style is a little dated but its a nice shift to 60 FPS.

Only thing to add is to include some elements to make it seem a little more spectacular, there were far too many moments where the image was just a black or white background with a sprite animation on top of it, which is a little boring on the eyes. There was just one moment where style seem to fit just well.

Aside from that, not bad!

PhilipSMBR responds:

Thank you for your helpful review! I'll be sure to keep that in mind for future animations I make ^^

[Sonic Test Animation]

You really ought to avoid submitting test animations to the portal.

Aside from that, it's alright. You got a foundation at least.

ElGermor responds:

Yeah, kinda figured that one out the hard way... Thanks non the less! :)

[Glenda, the classiest galaxy tourist - Extra 1]

This is so unnecessary but yet I love it so much, lmao. Keep these Glenda vids coming! Such professional quality!

SomeonesEx responds:

Thank you!

[Ways To Die: games | S1 E1| boymylife]

...That was something at least?

The jokes felt really stale and the whole movie was a bit painful to watch. The artwork definitely could've been better.

It's a start.

boymylife responds:

I agree the first bit is ok but the last bit is bad
but I'm proving those problems in my next one.

Thanks for your Feedback.

[003 1 hour challenge]

It's good... but there's really no entertainment value behind this. I feel like it'll belong better in the animation forums.

I will commend you on the smooth animation though.

Simrick responds:

Thanks for the feedback.

I will try and make them more watchable in the future and I will differelty be adding more colour into them as well.

[Animation Exercise - "Captain or Ma'am"]

It's really well made, but this sort of stuff should belong in the animation forums. Test animations don't really sit well here in the portal, plus you won't get the greatest of feedback compared to submitting it at the forums.

Still impressive regardless!

Annmariesch76 responds:

Oh thanks for letting me know! I dont use ng too often so idk how much of the stuff works XD